A Capital Choice!

Teacher's Guide

Home
Introduction
Task
Process
Resources
Conclusion

1.      Aim:  Students will be able to compare leading cities of David's kingdom and explain the risks and advantages of choosing various cities as the new capital.  They will also become aware of the great amount of scientific information available about what life was like 3,000 years ago, demonstrating that it is both preferable and realistic to make reports which are well-informed.

2.      Rationale:  Students are aware of Jerusalem as a touchstone of Jewish identity, but usually have little understanding of the way in which it came to occupy that role.  This unit of study will provide the students with an understanding of the basic factors that went into the choice of the Israelite national capital.

3.      Goals and objectives: students will:

a.      Discover some criteria of the tenth-century-BCE Middle East for evaluating cities

b.      Read a terrain map

c.      Read an archaeological map

d.      Compare and contrast some military strategies and tactics of attack and defense of cities in the 10th century BCE in the Middle East

e.      Integrate different aspects of archaeological data and other sources of information

f.       Make a pitch for a particular city to be selected as David's new Israelite capital

g.      Debate the choice among various contending cities as to which would make the best capital city for King David's Israel

h.      Express an informed opinion about the relative merits of various candidates to become the capital city of King David's Israel

4.      Audience and prerequisites:

a.      Students in grades 8-9 in a Jewish Day School

b.      Ongoing study of the Tanakh as a primary source

c.      A basic understanding of the Torah and the books of Joshua and Judges

d.      An in-depth acquaintance with the entire Book of I Samuel

e.       An immediate, solid understanding of the Book of II Samuel ch. 1-4

f.      A general knowledge of the geography of Israel and environs

5.  Description of subject matter:

a.      Archaeological excavation accounts

b.      Archaeological excavation maps

c.      Topographical maps of Israel and environs

d.      Individual artifacts from the Late Bronze and Early Iron Ages

e.      The Biblical account and evaluation of King David leading a strong, united Israel

f.   Biblical descriptions of various cities

g.       Historical analyses of the political, military, economic, and natural realities of the Middle East in the  tenth century BCE

6.      Instructional plan:

a.      Students will begin with a review of previously-studied information on a prefatory web page.  They will then proceed to the Introduction page, where their tasks will be summarized and they will read instructions for navigating the webquest site.

b.    The first task for the students is for each team of three to gather information about a different choice for the new capital for King David.  Each students will have to gather information about one of the following aspects of each candidate city:

     1)  The politics of location and accessibility

     2)  Topography and military defensibility

     3)  Economic resources, size of area, and size of population

c.      The candidate cities may include any or all of the following, at the discretion of the teacher:

      1)  Arad

      2)  Beth El

      3)  Dan

4)  Gezer

5)  Gibeon

6)  Hazor

7)  Megiddo

8)  Shechem

9)  Shilo

10) Tyre

(Jerusalem is left out on purpose, since the natural progression from this lesson is to discover Jerusalem's advantages.)

d.      The second task: students will report back to their teams and construct a presentation. This presentation is a mock briefing that they would be giving to King David as advisors helping the king to decide which city is the best choice.

e.      Presentations are given in front of the class in the computer lab.

f.      A brief period of deliberation across the classroom should follow, with the teacher moderating. A student should be chosen to record minutes of the discussion on the presentation monitor.  At the end of the discussion, the minutes should be published as a web page by the teacher so that each student can view them privately on a computer.

g.       After the deliberations, the students take a secret-ballot vote on that web page to choose the best city for the new capital of David's kingdom. Each ballot must contain a brief explanation of the reason for its choice.

h.  Homework:  read II Samuel chapter 5:1-10 and write down the instructions that David gives to his army when he attacks Jerusalem.  This sets up the investigation of why David chose Jerusalem, especially in light of the need to conquer it from a foreign people.

7.      Materials:

a.      Students must bring to the classroom:

1)     Several sheets of clean paper and two working writing implements

2)     Digital media, such as CD-RWs, CD-Rs, or flash memory unless they use floppies

3)     The Tanakh

4)     Any materials which are needed for the team presentation but are either not digital or not normally available in the classroom

b.      The teacher will provide:

1)     Three consecutive class periods reserved in the computer lab

2)     One computer per student in the lab

3)     Broadband internet access

4)     An online worksheet for students to use in organizing their researched information (See the Bib Sheet or the "Bib Sheet.pdf" file.

5)     Enough blank floppy disks for every student to use one individually

6)     An active printer available from all computers

7)     For the second task, a suitable presentation display space or monitor

8)     Presentation software, such as PowerPoint

9)     Table space for students to work on drawing or other non-digital presentation materials

10) Web browsing software, such as Internet Explorer

11) A "hotlist" of links to approved websites (see the Resources page or the "Resources.htm" file)

12) A member of the Technology staff or faculty for troubleshooting

8.      Plans for assessment and evaluation:

a.      Penalties should be assessed for exploring the internet beyond those resources listed on the Resources page, unless the teacher gives express permission to the individual student to do so.

b.      Each team member takes responsibility for researching one of the three topics listed above (6.b.1-3) for that team's assigned city. Work will be graded on the process of individual research as well as its fruits.  The Bib Sheet should be used to write information by hand, since this forces the student to process the information instead of simply copying and pasting from web pages.

c.      Presentations will be graded by team.

d.      Each ballot must contain an explanation of the reason for its choice. At the teacher's discretion, this step might also be done in handwriting, for the same reason as listed above in 8.b.  The class will receive a team grade on this activity.

11/06/2003